Michael Joseph | 21 January 2021 | 400 pgs
Source: Purchased 

If anyone ask me how would I describe C.J. Tudor's books, I'd say they're brooding and foreboding; and that she sure knows how to get her readers invested in the characters she's created. 

The Burning Girls started with a bang with an explosive prologue which the reader will soon know it's a flashback. What follows thereafter is our protagonist, Reverend Jack Brooks learning that she has to transfer to a small church in Chapel Croft until they've found a replacement. Jack doesn't want to go, partly of her 15-year-old daughter Flo, but they've given her no choice. 

Jack and Flo soon learn that Chapel Croft is far more than a quiet English countryside and it has a dark history surrounding the Sussex Martyrs during the religious persecutions of Queen Mary in 1556; whereby eight villagers were burnt at the stake, including two young girls. Each year on the anniversary of the purge, the residents will set alight of some small twig dolls they called Burning Girls to commemorate and honour the martyrs who died. As much as Jack is intrigued by this age-old tradition, she's more concerned about the suicide of her predecessor, Reverend Fletcher and the disappearance case of two young girls thirty years ago. No one knows what happened to Merry and Joy after all these time, but the residents assume that they'd simply run away from home and have gradually accepted their disappearance. 

As Jack and Flo try to adjust to their new life in this close-knit community, bad things start to happen. For starters, someone is sending her mysterious twig dolls, then Flo claims she's seen the apparitions of the burning girls in the chapel. And of course, the question that plagued Jack regarding Reverend Fletcher's suicide and why no one wants to talk about it. As much as Jack wants to find out the truth, she's also concerned about Flo's safety and well-being especially with her interactions with two teenage delinquents and a guy whom Flo just got acquainted with. And then, there's someone from Jack's past whom she tries to avoid has come to Chapel Croft for her.  

As you can see, there are multiple layers and subplots to this pacey story and despite the various threads Tudor has laid out, the conclusion was nicely tied up in a bow. The atmospheric setting was well done - from the creepy old chapel to an abandoned old building in the woods filled with graffiti of various evil symbols. The portrayal of the characters are vivid and believable; and I liked how Tudor created Reverend Jack Brooks to be a flawed, complex character with strength and weaknesses, as well as her role as both a (woman) vicar and a mother with different perspectives. Without saying more, this was an intense and a riveting suspense which I'm sure would thrill Tudor's fans and gain new readers as well. 

Last but not least, I want to thank Lark for reading this book with me as part of our buddy read "assignments". Please visit her blog for her review and the Q&A. Here's her questions to me:

1. This is the second book by C.J. Tudor that we've read together--which one did you like better, The Chalk Man or The Burning Girls? Why?
I enjoyed both of the books, but I think I loved this one a bit more because of the atmospheric setting, the characters (in particularly Reverend Jack Brooks and Flo) and the various genres/issues implemented into this story. (Click here for Chalk Man review.)

2. How do you feel about the role that the legend of the burning girls played in this novel? (Too much, or not enough?)
I'd expected that there'd be more backstory of the legend of the burning girls, but regrettably there aren't much elaborations about them as I thought the martyrdom might add more intrigue and depth to this story. Then again, this is only a part of Chapel Croft history and not the main core of the story so I'd let this pass. šŸ˜‰

© 2021 Melody's Reading Corner (, All Rights Reserved. If you are reading this post from other site(s), please take note that this post has been stolen and is used without permission.
16 Responses
  1. I read the first book by this author but not this one. It did enjoy the author's writing style in the one I read. Glad you liked this one.

  2. Lark Says:

    This was a fun one, Melody! I'm glad we got to read it together. And great review! :D

  3. thecuecard Says:

    I have not tried CJ Tudor's books yet but they sound good and spooky. It's great you two read it together.

  4. Melody Says:

    Diane - Tudor's writing and her storytellings are always so engaging. I'm curious to know what she'll write next.

  5. Melody Says:

    Lark - It was also fun discussing this book and of course, watching the story unravel as we went along. I hope our next book will be another great read! :)

  6. Melody Says:

    Thecuecard - I've enjoyed Tudor's books I read so far and I'd recommend them. Hope you'll give them a try one day. And I always enjoy the buddy reads with Lark. It's always fun to read a book together. :)

  7. jenclair Says:

    I really liked The Chalk Man and want to read this one, too!

  8. Melody Says:

    Jenclair - Hope you'll enjoy this book and I'll be curious of your thoughts, Jenclair.

  9. I really need to give this author a try, especially after reading your thoughts on it. You had me at brooding and foreboding.

  10. Kay Says:

    I really enjoyed your review of this book, Melody, and I love it when you and Lark 'buddy read'. I've read and really enjoyed The Chalk Man and maybe another by this author. Think I'll see about reading this one for the R.I.P. challenge. It fits, don't you think? LOL

  11. the bookworm Says:

    I'm glad you enjoyed this one! Brooding and foreboding sound good to me. The setting sounds good too. How fun to do a co-read too. Great review!

  12. Melody Says:

    Wendy - Although I've only read two of Tudor's books so far, I've enjoyed both of them. She's now one of my favourite authors. :)

  13. Melody Says:

    Kay - I think this book will make a good fit for the R.I.P. Challenge. I'll be curious of your thoughts if you do read this, Kay.

  14. Melody Says:

    Naida - Thanks, Naida! It's always fun to buddy read! :)

  15. Iliana Says:

    I love your buddy reviews. This one is definitely going on my TBR and I like it for the R.I.P. challenge!

  16. Melody Says:

    Iliana - It definitely fits the R.I.P. Challenge and I hope you'll enjoy it as much as I did.

Post a Comment

Thanks for stopping by! I would love to hear from you.